Dates of MBH Events-3
I found this chronology by
Prafulla Vaman Mendki in "Maabharata Study" Group, 1/19/2011, See it for yourself, how far it is
close to truth and how much can it be relied upon?
Sushma
MBH Events Preceded the Kali Yug:
Prafulla gives MBH dates another time like this ---
SN |
Description |
Date |
Tithi |
Nakshatra |
1 |
Draupadee-Paandav Vivaah |
2 Nov 3050 BC |
Paush Shukla 11 |
Rohinee |
2 |
Paandav got half kingdom |
3049 BC |
|
|
3. |
Arjun went for Vanvaas |
3042 BC |
|
|
4. |
Arjun-Subhadraa Marriage |
3031 BC |
|
|
5. |
Arjun returns, Abhimanyu birth |
3030 BC |
|
|
6. |
Draupadee's sons' Birth |
3031 - 3027 BC |
|
|
7. |
Yudhishthir's Raajsooya Yagya |
3023 - 3021 BC |
|
|
8. |
Paandav go to Vanvaas |
10 April 3021 BC |
Aashaadh Shukla 3 |
Pushya |
9. |
Paandav end Vanvaas |
10 April 3008 BC |
Jyeshth Krishn 11 |
Bharanee |
10. |
Kirmeeraa Vadh |
12 April 3021 BC |
Aashaadh Shukla 5 |
Maghaa |
11. |
Paanav went to Dwait Van |
21 May 3021 BC |
Shraavan Kishn 1 |
U-Aashaadh |
12. |
Arjun went to North |
25 May 3020 BC |
Shraavan Shukla 1 |
Pushya |
13. |
Arjun returns |
28 Jun 3015 BC |
Bhaadrapad Shukla 1 |
Poorv |
14. |
10 years completed in Kuber Van |
19 April 3011 BC |
Aashaadh Shukla 3 |
Pushya |
15. |
11 years completed in Vishaakh Yoop |
9 April 3010 BC |
Jyeshth Shukla 4 |
Pushya |
16. |
12 years completed, to Viraat Nagar |
27 April 3009 BC |
Aashaadh Shukla 3 |
Pushya |
17. |
Ghosh Yaatraa |
20 April 3010 BC |
Jyeshth Poornimaa |
Mool |
18. |
Keechak Vadh |
28 March 3008 BC |
Jyeshth Shukla 13 |
Vishaakhaa |
19. |
Susharmaa attacked Viraat |
6 April 3008 BC |
Jyeshth Krishn 7 |
P-Bhaadrapad |
20. |
Kaurav attacked Viraat |
7 April 3008 BC |
Jyeshth Krishn 8 |
U-Bhaadrapad |
21. |
Paandav appear |
10 April 3008 BC |
Jyeshth Krishn 11 |
Bharanee |
22. |
Uttaraa-Abhimanyu Vivaah |
16 April 3008 BC |
Aashaadh Shukla 3 |
Pushya |
23. |
Paandav sent diplomat |
14 May 3008 BC |
Shraava Shukla 1 |
Pushya |
24. |
Chaturdashee |
24 July 3008 BC |
Aashwin Poornimaa |
Revatee |
25. |
Panhdashee |
9 Aug 3008 BC |
Aashwin Amaavasyaa |
Chitraa |
26. |
Shodashee, penumbral Lunar eclipse |
24 Aug 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Poornimaa |
Bharanee |
27. |
Krishn as Messenger |
22 Aug 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Shukla 14 |
Revatee |
28. |
War fixed after 8 days |
30 Aug 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 5 |
Punarvasu/Pushya |
29. |
Armies in Kurukshetra (Moon near Maghaa) |
1 Sep 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 7 |
Aasheshaa/Maghaa |
30. |
Trayodashee |
7 Sep 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 13 |
Swati |
31. |
Geetaa |
8 Sep 3009 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 13 |
Vishaakhaa |
32. |
10th Day of war, Bheesh fell |
26 Sep 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 4 |
Punarvasu |
33. |
13th Day, Abhimanyu Vadh |
2 Oct 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Kishn 10 |
Hast |
34. |
14th day, Jayadrath Vadh |
4 Oct 3008 |
Kaarttik Krishn 12 |
Swaati |
35. |
15th day, Drone Vadh |
5 Oct 3008 BC |
Kaarttik Krishn 13 |
Vishaakhaa |
36. |
17th day, Karn Vadh |
9 Oct 3008 BC ** |
Maargsheersh Shukla 2 |
P-Aashaadh |
37. |
18th day, Shalya Vadh |
11 Oct 2008 BC ** |
Maargsheersh Shukla 4 |
Shravan |
|
Bheem Duryodhan fight |
|
|
|
38 |
Yudhishthir Raajya Abhishek |
17 Oct 3008 BC |
Maargsheersh Shukla 10 |
Ashwinee |
39. |
Meeting Bheeshm - 56 days for Maagh Shukla 8 |
19 Oct 3008 BC |
Maargsheersh Shkla 12 |
Krittikaa |
40. |
Bheeshm Upadesh |
20 Oct - 24 Oct |
|
|
41. |
Bheeshm spent 58 nights |
22 Nov 3008 BC |
Paush Poornimaa |
Aashleshaa |
42. |
Bheeshm Samaadhi |
14 Dec 3008 BC |
Maagh Shukla 8 |
Rohinee |
43. |
Bheeshm left-Uttaraayan begins |
17 Dec 3008 BC |
Maagh Shuka 11 |
Punarvasu |
44. |
Paandav went for treasure |
22 Dev 3008 BC |
Maagh Krishn 1 |
Uttar |
45. |
Ashwamedh started |
17 Feb 3007 BC |
Chaitra Poornimaa |
Chitraa |
46. |
Ashwamedh completed |
7 Feb 306 BC |
Chaitra Poornimaa |
Chitraa |
47. |
Kali Yug started |
23 Jun 3001 BC |
Bhaadrapad Krishn 13 |
|
48. |
Dhritraashtra Vanvaas |
7 Sep 2993 BC |
Kaarttik Poornimaa |
Krittikaa |
49. |
Dhritraashtra, Kuntee etc died |
2990 BC |
|
|
50. |
Dwaarkaa submerged |
2972 BC |
|
|
51. |
Paandav Swargaarohan |
2971 BC |
|
|
52. |
Pareekshit Raajya Abhishek |
2911 BC *** |
|
|
** Karn was killed the third day of Drone Vadh,
then how come that there is 4 days difference - it should be on 7th Oct.
In the same way, Shalya was killed the next day of Karn, then why the difference
of 2 days? It should be 10th Oct.
*** It means that Pareekshit sat on the throne
after 60 years of Paandav's Swargaarohan? But
MBH, Mahaaprasthaan
Parv says that Yudhishhir appointed Kripaa as the Guru of Pareekshit and
then left. So did Pareekshit take 60 years to be educated?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On the day of Krishn's
ascension, the Kali Yug started as mentioned in the Bhaagvat Puraan. That day
there was conjunction of all the stars, in and around the Revatee Nakshatra.
Very sorry to say that you worked very hard yet you got the date of Lord Krishna
wrong. Lord Krishna ascended on 17 / 18 February in 3102 BCE.
I am quoting below an excerpt from my #11141 in
IA forum, which proves conclusively that leave alone the conjunction of all the
"stars" (planets) in and around the Revatee Nakshatra, there was no conjunction
of even two "stars" (planets?) on that date (Feb 17/19, 3102 BCE) in any
Nakshatra by any stretch of imagination!
As such, to say that Kali Yug started on Feb
17/18, 3102 BCE is a myth created by some Greco-Chaldean astrologer, who
masqueraded as "Maya Mahaasur", and claimed in his good for nothing and the most
absurd astronomical work viz. the Soorya Siddhaant that the mean longitudes of
all the planets, except for the Raahu, were zero at the start of Kali Yug. He
did so only to make a fool of the Hindu, in which he succeeded beyond his own
expectations!
As such, God only knows when the Kali Yug started
actually, if at all it has started really, since there is no such indication
astronomically that it could have started during the past ten thousand years or
will ever start during the next ten thousand years, because all the "stars" were
not/are not going to be in conjunction near Revatee during that period of
twenty-thousand years!
Because of the same reasoning, it is impossible
that Krishn could have incarnated prior to 3102 BCE, since as per the royal
genealogy of the Bhaagvat Puraan and also the Vishnu Puraan, there is every
possibility that He could have Incarnated in around 1500 BCE. That also puts a
big question mark on the date of the Mahaabhaarat war having taken place prior
to around 2000 BCE at the earliest, whatever Prafulla Mendki or Prof Narhari
Achar may say!
[AK Kaul, Mahabharat Study Group, Jan 27, 2011]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 17/18 February of 3102 BCE it was Amaavasyaa;
and the other planets were not in a single point (ie. single degree of
longitude) but were around the Revatee. The longitudinal spread was about 22
degrees. Nowhere in any Puraan it is mentioned that all the Graha will not have
any longitudinal spread at all at that time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In support to show
Aadi Parv - 2.13 :
MBH war happened in Sandhi period of Dwaapar and Kali Yug
Van Parv - Teerth Yaatraa Parv 149.7 and 149.38 : Hanuman told Bheem that
Krit, Tretaa and Dwaapar time is over.
The time of destruction was started. Kali Yug is to start
soon.
Shalya Parv - 60.25 : Krishna told Balaraam - Assume that Kali Yug has started.
[It is wrong, it says that Kali Yug is at hand or Kali
Yug is about to come, see
G-6-War/38]
[Prafulla Mendki, Mahabharat Study Group, Jan 0, 2011]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sunil Bhattachaarya wrote
The 300-year Sandhi period of Dwaapar Yug was 3402 to 3102 BCE and the war
happened in 3139 BCE.
(3) Prafull Mendki wrote : Shalya Parv 60.25 : Shree Krishn told Balaraam :
Assume that Kali Yug has started.
The Dwaapar Yug Sandhi period started in 3402
BCE. In fact by 3139 BCE almost 88 % of the Sandhi period was over and only
about 12 % of the Sandhi period was remaining and that is why Lord Krishn was
telling Balaraam to know that Dwaapar Yug was almost over.
Further please note that the Bhaagvat Puraan says
that the Kali Yug started on the very day when Krishn ascended, (ie. in 3102
BCE). Bhaagvat Puraan also says that after the rule of Nand, ie. 1500 + 100 =
1600 years from the start of the Kali Yug the effect of Kali would became
severe.
See
history-bc2-326BC-800AD/12 to see that Bhaagvat Puraan says that
by the end of BCE, 2,800 years of Kali Yug had passed.
Read
Bhavishya Puraan,
3/4 to know about how does it describe advent of Kali Yug.
|